Together with our friends at Liverpool Pedestrians Association, MCC has put out the following statement in response to the sentencing of Paul Doyle following the horrific road rage incident earlier this year:
First and foremost, our thoughts are with those harmed by this incident and with all who have been affected by it. No one should have to fear for their life whilst in public spaces.
Once again, an individual bears a heavy burden of punishment while the deeper issue risks being overlooked. This case is not only about one man’s actions, but about a wider culture that normalises danger, aggression and the lethal impact of motor vehicles.
Judge Menary described Paul Doyle as using his motor vehicle as a “weapon”. This is accurate. But when will our society demonstrate the moral courage to admit to the horrific daily violence caused by the operation of motor vehicles, instead of blithely sanctioning their mass use at colossal cost to life in general?
To entomb ourselves in powerful motor vehicles, however carefully they may be used, is a degradation to our humanity. We become distanced from one another and have our sense of responsibility dulled. Enormous levels of harm ensue. For people who walk, wheel and cycle, road danger is a lived reality: intimidation, abuse, near misses, and constant vulnerability.
If anything meaningful is to come from this case it must be a reckoning with the culture that surrounds motor vehicle use and how all lives – not only human ones – outside cars are endangered, devalued and treated as obstacles.
We offer these words not in anger, but in the hope that this moment prompts reflection, honesty, and a collective commitment to diminish the violence so prevalent in our midst.
Alongside the open letter above, MCC has sent out a short companion briefing to all councillors and senior decision-makers in the Liverpool City Region, with the aim of translating the moral and cultural concerns raised in the letter into a policy and leadership context.
The central argument is simple: road danger is not an unfortunate by-product of economic activity, but a predictable outcome of long-standing priorities that place vehicle speed and flow above human safety. Vision Zero (a strategy to eliminate all traffic fatalities and severe injuries) will only be taken seriously if political choices, and the hierarchy of priorities behind them, are openly addressed.
Our streets should be places of connection and movement, not fear and mourning. A city region that values walking and cycling is one that values care, restraint and shared responsibility.

